FOR COMPANION ANIMALS:
Rabies is widespread in Canada, although, traditionally, the majority of reported cases have occurred in Ontario (85%), and to a lesser extent, in Saskatchewan (10%). Since1958, over 60,000 rabies cases have been recorded, with approximately 75% of them occurring in wildlife and the remainder in livestock and companion animals. Between 1965 and 1986, annual diagnoses of rabies varied between 1,400 and 2,500 across Canada, peaking at 4,131 cases in 19861,2. Since that time, there has been a dramatic decline in the number of reported rabies cases in all species; in 1997, 238 cases were reported of which 100 were in Ontario, 56 in Manitoba, 39 in Quebec and 16 in Saskatchewan. Although all mammals can be infected with rabies virus, strains of rabies virus have been identified that have predilections for certain species. The control of the fox strain in Ontario in the last 10 years through oral baiting is primarily responsible for the significant decline in reported rabies cases. Unfortunately, a raccoon strain of rabies moving up from the US threatens this control, and there are still significant numbers of bats and skunks diagnosed with rabies.
Although prior to 1945, dogs accounted for the majority of the cases of rabies in Canada, vaccination, animal control, and regulatory measures have reduced the incidence of rabies in dogs. Vaccines for dogs are currently available with one, two and three year label recommendations, while cats have one and three year rabies vaccines available. Despite the availability of vaccines providing longer term duration of immunity, many veterinarians in Canada continue to use the rabies vaccine on an annual basis, even when using triennial products. In some cases, there appears to be significant confusion as to regulatory requirements; in others, there may be a lack of confidence in triennial products being used according to label recommendations.
Vaccine Use Across Canada-The Provinces
In a telephone survey of the use of rabies vaccines across Canada, significant variability existed with regard to revaccination policies or procedures. In Newfoundland, small animal practices currently recommend triennial vaccination; some practitioners have even discontinued rabies vaccination for indoor cats and those that do not travel outside the island. Dogs and cats in areas of Labrador with minimal private veterinary care receive vaccination from lay vaccinators, usually public health nurses. Although a triennial schedule is recommended for these pets, the nature of the vaccination times prevents strict adherence to this policy; pets are often vaccinated only when vaccinations are available in the communities. Emphasis is given to vaccinating in the months prior to an anticipated outbreak.
Although the City of Halifax, with 35% of the population of Nova Scotia, previously requested annual revaccination in order for pet owners to receive a discount on pet licenses, the majority of practitioners in the province revaccinate triennially against rabies. Pets that are travelling may receive annual revaccination if proceeding to areas where vaccination against rabies is required annually by law.
Like practitioners in Nova Scotia and Newfoundland, practitioners on Prince Edward Island recommend triennial vaccination, unless pets are travelling. The New Brunswick VMA recommends annual revaccination for rabies, with some New Brunswick municipalities requiring proof of annual vaccination in order to obtain a pet license. The decision to vaccinate annually may be due, in part, to recommendations in Ontario to do the same. In Quebec, most veterinarians administer rabies vaccines annually, although some veterinarians in Montreal vaccinate biennially.
Ontario has widespread use of annual revaccination protocols, primarily due to confusion over legal requirements and due to the historically high incidence of rabies in the province. In a review of vaccination policies in 1996, the small animal committee of the Ontario Veterinary Medical Association recommended annual revaccination, although the association has not endorsed the recommendation.
Practitioners in Manitoba vaccinate annually to triennially. In one practice, for example, dogs are vaccinated every 2 years, cats every three years. In Saskatchewan, practitioners apply the triennial protocol to low risk animals, presumably they vaccinate higher risk pets more frequently. Alberta has no standard policy; the majority of pets are vaccinated against rabies biennially or triennially. In British Columbia, veterinarians give the vaccine every three years.
Despite the variation in protocols for revaccinating against rabies around the country, all vaccination protocols require an initial vaccination after 3 months of age and a booster at a year of age.
The Veterinary Colleges
Recommended protocols for vaccination against rabies also vary with each veterinary college. Both the Ontario Veterinary College and the Faculte de Medicine Veterinaire recommend using rabies vaccines according to the label recommendations and encourage the use of triennial products. The Atlantic Veterinary College recommends annual use for pets travelling to Ontario, on the presumption that there are legal requirements in Ontario for annual vaccination against rabies. The Western College of Veterinary Medicine recommends annual vaccination for those pets travelling or for pets that may have exposure to wildlife.
In response to concerns over the efficacy of using triennial rabies vaccines, the following describes regulatory requirements and biologic manufacturers' trials and experience with the vaccines.
Vaccines against rabies are licensed according to challenge studies for the term that the license is granted. In Canada, the Veterinary Biologics and Biotechnology Section of the Animal Health and Production Division, Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA), regulates and licenses rabies vaccines for either one, two or three years. All rabies vaccines currently licensed in Canada for companion animal and livestock animal use are manufactured in the United States. Minimum standards for accepting vaccination challenge studies are described in the Code of Federal Regulations (9-CFR). Challenge is conducted by live rabies virus injected into the masseter muscle of animals that have received a single dose of vaccine. At the end of the challenge study, 22 out of 25 (88%) or 26 out of 30 (87%) of the vaccinates must resist challenge to the virus, lethal enough to kill 80% of the controls. It must be recognized that all vaccines currently on the market exceed the requirement. In addition, manufacturers must satisfy regulatory concerns over safety, purity and potency of vaccines to allow sale of the vaccine in Canada.
Until recently, manufacturers of vaccines against rabies provided a caveat to biennial and triennial revaccination, suggesting that animals in high risk areas may benefit from more frequent revaccination than recommended on the label. Presently, vaccines licensed for triennial use no longer carry this caveat, recommending only that the vaccine be given according to label recommendations. Prorab (Intervet Canada, Whitby, Ontario) has just received government approval for a similar statement to be removed and its label is due to be changed very soon. The removal of the caveat is due to the lack of scientific data to support such a caveat.
The Federal Rabies Control Program, managed by the CFIA, regulates rabies in Canada for investigation, submissions and quarantine. The period of quarantine of a rabies contact domestic pet is determined by the revaccination schedule recommended by the Compendium of Animal Rabies Control. A dog or cat vaccinated with a two or three year product that had exposure to a rabid animal would require quarantine for 30 days to 3 months, the same as a pet vaccinated with an annual vaccine, provided the vaccinations had not expired for their licensed terms. However, should the pet be unvaccinated or have an expired vaccination at the time of rabies exposure, quarantine is at least six months.
CFIA also regulates the importation of dogs and cats into Canada. Dogs and cats entering Canada must have proof of having been vaccinated against rabies within three years and more than 30 days from the date of travel.
Contrary to widespread belief, there is no provincial legal requirement for annual revaccination for rabies in Ontario, nor in any other Canadian province. In Ontario, where annual revaccination against rabies is common, the legal requirements for revaccination are often misunderstood5. Ontario Regulation (OR) 567/90 governs the compulsory vaccination against rabies in Ontario, requiring that cats and dogs receive vaccination against rabies in those areas where risk is considered high6. Section 3 of the regulation, states "every animal...shall be re-immunized in accordance with the date prescribed in the certificate of immunization issued with respect to the animal", and Section 4(b), states that "Immunization against rabies shall be...by inoculation with a rabies vaccine that is licensed for use in Canada and that is administered in accordance with the instructions of the manufacturer who produced the vaccine".
According to Dr. Chuck Leber of the Ontario Ministry of Health, "If a health unit determines that a pet was vaccinated against rabies more than 12 months but less than 36 months from the previous one and the vaccine has a three year duration, the animal is immunized and the owner cannot be charged for violation of OR567. However, if the vaccine has a one year duration, the owner could be charged. In any event, neither health units nor the Ontario Ministry of Health is in a position to indicate what duration of vaccine is to be used". Currently, 31 health units in Ontario require compulsory rabies vaccination. In contacting the health units, all confirmed that the decision to revaccinate is governed by the above regulation and determined by the local veterinarians; however, a small number have recommended annual revaccination after consultation with local veterinary groups.
United States of America
In the USA, the use of rabies vaccines is guided by recommendations from the National Association of State Public Health Veterinarians, which are published in the annual Compendium of Animal Rabies Control. According to the Compendium, "In comprehensive rabies control programs, only vaccines with a 3-year duration of immunity should be used" and animals should be vaccinated in accordance with the label recommendations for the vaccines. Although some veterinarians and some states continue to endorse or require the use of rabies vaccines more frequently, most follow the label recommendations for triennial vaccines. In 9 of 22 US veterinary colleges, rabies is still required annually by state law; the rest recommend triennial vaccination7. Efforts are currently underway to remove state regulatory requirements for annual rabies revaccination where it still exists.
For pets entering the USA from Canada, the Centre for Disease Control of the Department of Health and Human Services regulates importation and also requires proof of vaccination against rabies in dogs, recognizing the date of vaccination expiry depending on the type of vaccine used8. If the appropriate date of vaccination expiry is not mentioned, the requirement for revaccination defaults to annual. Interestingly, cats entering the USA are exempt from requiring proof of having been vaccinated against rabies. Despite this, it appears that pet owners crossing into the USA may, on occasion, be asked for proof of rabies vaccination within a year due to confusion over the regulation by US Customs officials. Furthermore, fourteen members of the International Air Transport Association (IATA) have published a Travel Information Manual which incorrectly advises travelers that proof of vaccination for rabies more than 30 days and less than twelve months is required for travel into the USA from Canada.
Pets residing in the United States will be under further regulation by the State of residence. Owners should inquire as to the specific requirements for rabies vaccination in each area. Information on specific State requirements can be obtained through the USDA web site at: www.aphis.usda.gov/vs/sregs/. Because proof of vaccination within a twelve month period, and more than 30 days, is required for travel to some other countries, veterinarians and pet owners are advised to check appropriate regulations prior to travel.
Concerns with Re-vaccination Protocols
Impetus to reconsider rabies revaccination protocols follows an increased veterinary and public awareness of potential serious side-effects with respect to vaccination. Rabies vaccines have been implicated in the development of life-threatening fibrosarcomas in cats; vaccines have also been associated with other adverse disorders, such as immune-mediated thrombocytopenias and anemias9. As a result, some veterinary groups and veterinary schools have begun advocating the less frequent use of vaccines, and only to animals considered to be at significant risk.
In February of 1998, the CVMA met with representatives of the Canadian Animal Health Institute, representing the manufacturers of biologics, and the Veterinary Biologics and Biotechnology Section of the CFIA, and their counterparts in the USDA. After hearing presentations from Dr. Stephen Kruth of the University of Guelph, and Dr. John Ellis of the University of Saskatchewan, the CVMA published a statement on vaccine protocols, recommending that, at this time, veterinarians use biologics according to label recommendations. As many veterinarians in Ontario and Quebec and some in other parts of Canada continue to use rabies vaccines more frequently than is recommended by the label, the potential exists for the public to question the use of the vaccine, unless more frequent use is justifiable. This can seriously erode veterinarians' credibility with regards to their current recommendations for all vaccines.
Efficacy of 3-Year Vaccines
Proof of efficacy of a triennial vaccine is provided not only through regulatory testing but by trials conducted by manufacturers themselves. According to three manufacturers of three year rabies products, their vaccines provided anywhere from 90 to 100% efficacy from challenge with rabies virus after only one vaccine dose, in both dogs and cats. Results for one year products were not significantly better10. Furthermore, there are a large number of reports in the literature of challenge studies to rabies vaccines, three years post vaccination, showing effective immunity11.
Efficacy of triennial vaccines used in the field is demonstrated from two sources. Bech-Nielsen et al. concluded that, in Illinois, the transition from one year to three year licensed products "did not significantly affect the number of reported dog rabies cases in the six years following the change. This is an example of the typical experience associated with change in legislated vaccination schedule"12. Also, New York State has experienced a huge increase in the incidence of rabies over the last ten years, going from an average of less than 40 to over 1000 cases annually, including wildlife, farm animals and companion animals. In 1993, 2,746 cases were reported in that year alone. Despite the increase, blamed primarily on the influx of the raccoon strain of rabies into the State, there has been no significant increase in the incidence of rabies in vaccinated dogs and cats. Dr. Chuck Trimarchi of the New York State Department of Health confirmed that there is widespread use of triennial products in New York State among veterinarians.
Previous studies have found up to 14% dogs or cats diagnosed with rabies as having previously received rabies vaccines13,14,15. The 1988 study found that out of 119 cases of rabies in dogs and cats for that year, 18 of the animals had previously received rabies vaccination. However, upon further analysis, 14 had expired vaccinations, either with one year or three year vaccines. Two cats and two dogs diagnosed with rabies that had current vaccinations for rabies had received only the first vaccination and no booster a year later, one of which had received the rabies vaccine within a month of illness and may have been infected prior to vaccination.
CFIA has informal data to suggest up to 10% of dogs and 3% of cats diagnosed with rabies between 1993 and 1995 had previously received rabies vaccines16. Unfortunately, at this time, details of the vaccination status of the animals, age of animals, number of previous vaccines and types of vaccines used are not known. With regards to three year products, Dr. Suzanne Jenkins, staff epidemiologist and chairperson for the U.S. National Association of State Public Health Veterinarians, is not aware of any cases of rabies in dogs or cats in the US where the pets have received the first rabies vaccine followed by the first booster one year later, as is recommended by the manufacturer's label; reports do exist of pets having received only the initial vaccination developing after contact with a carrier animal.
There is a need to re-examine the widespread annual re-vaccination against rabies in companion animals in parts of Canada, particularly where triennially licensed products are used. Contrary to widely held beliefs, legal requirements for annual rabies revaccination exist in only a few local jurisdictions, mostly in New Brunswick. The decision of which type of rabies vaccine to use, and the frequency of vaccination is determined solely by the veterinarian in most places.
While significant data supports the efficacy of triennial vaccines used according to the label recommendations, more studies are needed to assess field efficacy. Beginning in 1999, the Center for Disease Control in the United States will be conducting a prospective study on rabies in the US, collecting further information on vaccination status and types of vaccines used for dogs and cats that contract rabies.
Given concerns with adverse reactions to vaccines, in particular the association between rabies vaccines and feline fibrosarcomas, revaccination protocols should be designed to maximize protection of the pet and public, while minimizing unnecessary boosters.
Rosatte, Richard C. Rabies in Canada: History, Epidemiology and Control, Can Vet J. 1988;129:362-365
Data on file: rabies statistics, Canadian Food Inspection Agency, Animal Health and Production Division, 1998.
Personal communications, provincial VMA's..
Westgarth-Taylor, B. Rabies Re-vaccination. Focus 1996; Vol. 15. No 2. p14
Gumley, N. Rabies Revaccination in Ontario for Companion Animals, Part One, FOCUS magazine, Ontario Veterinary Medical Association, Jan/Feb 1999
Current Health Units requiring vaccination of dogs and cats:
Brant County; Bruce-Grey-Owen Sound; East York; Eastern Ontario; Elgin-St. Thomas; Etobicoke; Haldimand-Norfolk; Haliburton-Kawartha-Pine Ridge; Halton Region; Hastings, Prince Edward; Huron County; Kent-Chatham; Kingston-Frontenac and Lennox and Addington; Lambton; Leeds-Grenville and Lanark; Middlesex-London; Niagara Region; North York; Oxford County; Perth District; Peterborough; Ottawa-Carleton; Scarborough; Simcoe County; Sudbury District; Toronto City; Wellington-Dufferin-Guelph; Windsor-Essex; York City; York Region.
Thompson, S. North American Veterinary Teaching Hospital Vaccination Survey, Mid '98. Trends Magazine, American Animal Hospital Association, Dec. 1998
Title 42, Code of Federal Regulations Vol. 1 Part 1 - 399, page 506 - 510 (Rev. Oct. '96)
Smith CA.. Are We Vaccinating Too Much? JAVMA 1995; 207: 421-425.
Propriety data: Pfizer, Ayerst, Merial, 1998
Burr et al. Duration of Immunity in Companion Animals After Natural Infection and Vaccination. Published by Pfizer Animal Health, June, 1998.
Bech-Nielsen, S. et al. Vaccination Against Dog Rabies in the United States JAVMA 1979; 174: 695-699.
Kappus KD. Canine rabies in the United States, 1971-1973: study of reported cases with reference to vaccination history. Am J Epidemiol 1976; 103:242-249.
Crane SL, Baer GM. Reported canine and feline rabies in the United States between 1980 and 1983. Rabies Information Exchange 1986; 15:38-43.
Eng. TR, Fishbein DB. Epidemiologic facors, clinical findings, and vaccination status of rabies in cats and dogs in the United States in 1988. JAVMA 1990; 197:201-209
Personal Communication, Dr. Ron Rogers, Canadian Food Inspection Agency 1998